• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Follow Us

Carrot Created with Sketch.
  • Sign In
  • Subscribe
  • Start Here
    • About WWL
    • Press
  • Recipes
    • Top Rated
    • Baked Goods
    • Beef
    • Breakfast Meal Preps
    • College Friendly
    • Freezer Friendly
    • Gluten-Free
    • Kid-Friendly
    • No Reheat Meals
    • One Pot Meals
    • Pantry Meals
    • Poultry
    • Salads
    • Seafood
    • Snacks
    • Soup
    • Under 30 Minutes
    • Vegan
    • Vegetarian
    • Wraps & Sandwiches
  • Blog
    • Meal Prep Pro Tips
    • Cooking For Two (Or More)
    • Intuitive Eating
    • Healthy Habits
    • Kitchen & Meal Prep Essentials
    • Recipe Roundups
    • Save Money
    • Save Time
    • Sustainable Meal Prep
  • Member’s Area
  • Join The Team
    • WWL Program Recipe Submission!
    • The WWL Team

ButcherBox: Is It Worth It? (My Full Review – 2021)

February 10, 2021 by Talia Koren 1 Comment

Maybe you’ve heard of ButcherBox, the meat subscription so many use and love, and are wondering… is it worth it?

In this post, I’m sharing my detailed ButcherBox review, including what we normally get, how much it costs and how it compares to other meat buying options.

This post is sponsored by ButcherBox, but you should know I used (and loved) the service for years before partnering with them. I still buy all my own boxes as well and am a regular customer.

ButcherBox also runs special deals for new members! Click here to see what the newest deal is.

 

What's In This Post

  • All about ButcherBox and Why We Use It
  • How ButcherBox works for us
  • What do you order in your ButcherBox?
  • How often do you get a box?
  • Where does the meat come from?
  • How much does it cost?
  • 7 Recipes we love using ButcherBox meat
  • The Bottom Line

All about ButcherBox and Why We Use It

ButcherBox, came on my radar years ago when I really got into cooking and meal prep.

I remember seeing a post on Instagram about it and thought it was such a good idea right off the bat! Free-range organic chicken and grass-fed right to my door? Yes, please!

Why I signed up:

Even though I’ve incorporated meat into my diet all my life, buying meat has always intimidated me. I never wanted to stare at the options in the store for hours, with no idea what to get and getting in the way of other shoppers. I’d often feel lost and not super confident in my meat choices.

But since starting with ButcherBox a few years ago, I no longer feel that fear around buying meat. It’s not something I have to worry about anymore every time I food shop.

I’ve used ButcherBox, which recently became a B Corp certified business, on and off for the past few years to get high-quality meat to store in the freezer and use in my meal preps and would absolutely recommend it to folks who eat meat regularly and feel the same stress when buying meat at the regular grocery store!

How ButcherBox works for us

There are a few different box options on ButcherBox! You can choose boxes based on meat types, like a beef-only box or a chicken and beef box. I always go for the custom box because we love to change it up and select the cuts of meat we need.

You can also choose the size of your box – we go for the smaller option because it’s just two of us and we don’t eat meat every day. But the big box would be perfect for a larger family!

The smaller custom box costs $149 with no add ons and it holds 9-14 pounds of meat. The larger size is $270 per box and it holds 18-26 pounds. Keep reading to learn more about my opinions on the cost-effectiveness of ButcherBox.

What do you order in your ButcherBox?

I always order a bunch of chicken breasts, chicken thighs, a whole chicken and ground beef. These are what we use most often!

Sometimes I’ll add different cuts of steak (I love ButcherBox’s stew beef and strip steaks) or different pork cuts (bacon, pork chops or ground pork). Depending on the month, ButcherBox offers fun add ons.

In our last box, we got this delicious BBQ pulled pork. We still talk about it all the time – it was that good!

You can add seafood, ground turkey and hot dogs depending on what’s being offered as well. I love that each time I order a box, it can be a little different!

How often do you get a box?

We get a new ButcherBox every 3 months. We eat plant-based half of the time so it takes us a little longer to get through it all! You can get a box every four, six, or eight weeks, though. This totally depends on your preference and you can pause or cancel at any time with no penalties.

I love that we can control how often a box arrives at our door. With ButcherBox, you only pay for a box when it’s ordered – you don’t pay a monthly base membership fee on top of the boxes like other subscriptions. They’ll also give you a heads up before your box comes so you can change what’s in it or the timing.

Wondering about the packaging? The meat usually comes in a package that’s 100% made with recycled materials and can be recycled, according to the ButcherBox website. I find it pretty easy to deal with!

Where does the meat come from?

ButcherBox sources its beef from Australia. Their beef is humanely raised,grass-fed and grass-finished, and free from added hormones and antibiotics.

The chicken and pork come from the US. ButcherBox raises Heritage-breed hogs sustainably and humanely. Their chickens are free-range and organic as well.

If you want to get seafood from ButcherBox, know that it’s sourced from North America (Alaska, Maine, and Gorges Bank).

Having worked with ButcherBox for over a year now, it’s clear they care not only about the quality of the meat, but the way the animals are raised as well. It’s hard to get this level of transparency when standing in front of the refrigerated meat section in a grocery store!

How much does it cost?

While there are many different options for buying meat, I’ve found ButcherBox to be worth the price for the quality and convenience.

We love that we can buy quality meat in one go, from one trusted source, and freeze it all to use in meal prep! When it comes to cost, we have to consider the time cost as well. Could we search our neighborhood for the best meat deals and try to spend as little as possible? Yes. But I’d rather not spend time doing that.

Buying cuts of chicken, beef and pork every week at the regular grocery store can really add up. I’d rather spend more upfront and keep a stash in my freezer. This also makes it easier to put a meal together without going grocery shopping, thanks to having a stocked freezer and pantry.

As I mentioned before, we get a classic small custom box that costs $149. We choose six cuts to add to the box, which usually gives our family around 30 portions of meat. That comes to about $5 per serving of meat in a box! Not bad.

One box usually lasts us about 3 months, if not longer. Thanks to ButcherBox, we rarely buy beef and chicken at the grocery store, which helps us save in the long run.

Since we’re not buying a box every month, we break it down to $50/month in our food budget for meat.

ButcherBox Vs The Grocery Store

At the grocery store, you can buy meat in bulk too and save, but the packaging doesn’t lend itself well to being frozen for a long time. There’s a lot of air in the meat packages at the grocery store, which means more freezer burn.

ButcherBox’s meat is all vacuum sealed, so no air gets inside. The meat lasts a lot longer in the freezer that way!

ButcherBox Vs Costco

I found Costco’s packaging to be better for buying meat in bulk since it’s vacuum-sealed as well, but the chicken packages are a little too big for what we like to use in one recipe. For chicken at Costco especially, their packages usually have two pounds while we only need one pound between the two of us most of the time. You can’t freeze, thaw, and re-freeze meat, so this packaging matters!

Costco sells solid ground beef and turkey too, but the quality and taste of ButcherBox’s meat is noticeably better here in my opinion.

Everyone has different needs, and it’s great we have so many options for buying meat, but ButcherBox has made the most sense for my family so far.

Click here to try it out and get a special offer on your first box! 

7 Recipes we love using ButcherBox meat

20-Minute Swiss Chard Pasta

Chicken Noodle Soup

Jalapeno Cheddar Bacon Waffles

Beef Banh Mi Bowls

Orange Baked Chicken

Basil Lime Peach Chicken Salad

Steak Fajitas

The Bottom Line

If you find yourself constantly buying meat at the grocery store and want to take thinking about meat off your mental plate, ButcherBox is a great idea.

Since you can control how often a box comes, it’s not like you have to get meat every month! Being able to choose the meat in your box each time you get one allows for so much flexibility and control.

It’s worth every penny if you ask me, and I’d still say the same even if ButcherBox hadn’t sponsored this post as a long time member of their subscription.

Try it out here!

Filed Under: Blog, Meal Prep Pro Tips

Comments

  1. Sara M

    February 10, 2021 at 4:41 pm

    Thanks so much for a very helpful post!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




Share this article

Primary Sidebar

Get weekly meal prep tips from me!

Recent Posts

  • Chickpea, Spinach, Onion and Red Pepper Pita Wraps with Tahini Yogurt Sauce

    Chickpea, Spinach, Onion and Red Pepper Pita Wraps with Tahini Yogurt Sauce

  • Individual Chicken Pot Pies | Workweek Lunch

    Individual Chicken Pot Pies | Workweek Lunch

  • Freezer Meal Prep: Stock Your Freezer With 8 Easy Prep Recipes

    Freezer Meal Prep: Stock Your Freezer With 8 Easy Prep Recipes

workweeklunch

Workweek Lunch | Talia Koren
Pancake pros! What are your BEST tips for making p Pancake pros! What are your BEST tips for making perfect pancakes? Share below! 🥞
.
❓And if you absolutely wouldn’t describe yourself as a pancake pro, what are your pancake struggles?
.
🤔I’ve been getting a lot of pancake questions lately in DMs and in our private WWL Program Facebook group (the most incredible food community on FB!) and I want to make a video with the best tried and true tips for expert level pancakes.
.
🥞Pancakes are one of our favorite breakfasts for meal prep! They reheat great in the microwave, toaster or on the stove and there are SO MANY flavor combinations to try.
.
🙌🏼We have several pancake recipes in the WWL Program - matcha, lemon blueberry, chocolate chip cherry and pumpkin to name a few. In this photo we have our favorite banana pancake recipe. Sign up for the WWL Program in my bio link to get access to all our breakfast meal prep recipes and more!
You’re not a doughnut or a piece of zucchini bre You’re not a doughnut or a piece of zucchini bread. You’re a human who needs food and nourishment to show up at their best in this world. 💕
.
MEALS:
.
Zucchini carrot “confetti” bread - coming to WWL soon
.
Chickpea Greek salad wraps - dropped in the WWL Program yesterday
.
Mongolian-inspired beef - coming to WWL soon
.
Sprinkled doughnut from @mightyodonuts 🍩
.
Grab our recipes, non-diet meal plans and grocery lists  when you sign up for the WWL Program in my bio link!
QUICK MEAL PREP TIPS . 👉🏼Choose meals you ca QUICK MEAL PREP TIPS
.
👉🏼Choose meals you can easily multitask - like cooking one meal on the stove while you cook something else in the oven or another appliance (slow cooker, Instant Pot)
.
👉🏼Opt for rotisserie chicken or low maintenance proteins like hard boiled eggs to cut down time in the kitchen
.
👉🏼Pre-cut veggies can also save you tons of time, but they’re more expensive! If that’s out of your budget, consider doing all your chopping 1 day before you prep and assemble meals
.
👉🏼Never meal plan, shop and cook on the same day. I like to meal plan on Friday, shop on Saturday and cook on Sunday.
.
👉🏼Meals like overnight oats, smoothies, skillets, one-pot pastas and salad wraps are reliably fast!
.
🙌🏼All the meals pictured (except the parfaits) are featured in this week’s new WWL meal plan for members of the WWL Program! Grab this plan + all our recipes and custom meal planning tools when you sign up in my bio link! We offer a 7-day free trial, then it’s just $9.99/mo (or less when you sign up for 6-12 months) to keep meal prepping with our plans, recipes and community.
I like to say all good things start with a spreads I like to say all good things start with a spreadsheet 🤓including affordable, delicious meal preps!
.
Save this post for next time you need a quick reminder of how to make simple meal plans you’ll actually stick to!
.
👩🏻‍🍳There’s no way I could pull off these meal preps week after week (for years and years) without solid planning. It’s something I do every Friday, the day before I shop and 2 days before I prep.
.
😅Do you have to make your meal plan on a spreadsheet? No! You can do it in your notes app, on paper, on a white board, with apps or services like WWL Program - however works for you. I use excel because everything I plan isn’t in the WWL Program yet 😜
.
👈🏼Swipe to the last slide for my simple 3 steps to making a meal plan.
.
💕Of course there’s an intuitive eating approach to this: I don’t follow the plan exactly during the week. Meaning I might it eat my chickpea wraps for dinner instead of lunch one day. The point of filling in the grid is to make sure I have the meals I want to plan for covered. When life gets randomly crazy, it’s ok if the plan goes out the window.  Of course these days, it’s pretty slow and steady 😂
.
If you need help@with meal planning or just hate sitting down to do it, we can help. The WWL Program has some awesome planning tools that help you feel organized AND it automatically makes a grocery list for you based on the meals you choose for the week.  Sign up for a free trial in my bio link! After your free week, it’s $9.99/mo.
.
👇🏼What’s your meal planning medium these days? Excel? Pen and paper? Our Program? Share in the comments!!
.
.
.
.
RECIPES: “confetti” bread, chickpea Greek salad wraps and Mongolian-inspired ground beef and broccoli are all coming to the WWL Program for members soon!
Chopped Greek salad, a love story💕 . 🥬I used Chopped Greek salad, a love story💕
.
🥬I used to buy a big chopped Greek salad at a takeout place called Così a few times per week. I’ll be honest, it’s mostly because the bread they served with the salad was amazing and it was a $7.50 lunch for me. When I started meal prepping, OBVIOUSLY Greek salad was something I tried to make often, but always failed. It was just soooo soggy and sad.
.
🍅Eventually, with practice, I figured it out. The key is using fresh herbs, a good dressing and ditching lettuce altogether or keeping it on the side to add before eating. And bundling the salad up in a wrap makes it easier to eat and take on the go.
.
🌯This salad (with a chicken version) and wrap is dropping on Wednesday in the WWL Program in our brand new MINIMAL COOKING meal plan! That’s right. The veg version of this requires no heat/appliances. And the omnivore version only has you quickly cooking chicken!
.
👉🏼To get this recipe and plan when it drops, head over to my bio link to sign up for the WWL Program! We share a new plan and recipes every week so you never get bored.
.
Chicken wrap photo credit: @pinkleme and credit to my partner for holding the spoon in the action shots 😂
Since I have a bunch of new folks here - welcome! Since I have a bunch of new folks here - welcome! I’m Talia and here’s what you need to know about Workweek Lunch👇🏼
.
👉🏼WWL is a meal plan subscription with thousands of members all over the world and resource for all things meal prep, meal planning and practical cooking *without* a side of diet culture. We don’t share calorie/nutrition info, we don’t talk about weight loss tips or restriction of any kind (see my intuitive eating story highlight for more info). I’m not here to tell you what to eat, how much or how often. 🤗 I’m here to help make it *easier* for you to eat however makes you feel your best.
.
👩🏻‍🍳I don’t have a formal background in cooking or dietetics. I’m just really organized and have a lot of cooking experience! Meal planning and prepping has always come easily to me and I love helping others.
.
💸I started meal prepping right after graduating college to save money living in NYC! And because I wanted to restrict food to be the smallest version of myself. 😣 My first kitchen was tiny, had no working oven and had a bug issue (that’s NYC for you) but I still got meal prep done and managed to save enough for an emergency fund and some snowboarding trips!
.
🤘🏼Now I meal prep because it’s the only way for me to work as much as I want to during the week and helps me have more mental energy for important decisions. Can’t say we are saving money at this point because our cost of living has been pretty low for years thanks to our meal prep routine. And I no longer use meal prep as a tool to force my body to be a size it wasn’t meant to be.
.
👩🏻‍💻Workweek Lunch is my full time job. We have an amazing team of 5 (3 of us are full time) and I LOVE what I do.
.
🏔Other basics: I’m 28, I live with my partner in Seattle and I love hiking, snowboarding, camping and solo travel.
.
❓how can I help? Tell me what you’re looking forward to seeing here on my feed! And stay tuned in stories for today’s #mealprepsunday sesh.
I used to have so many food rules that made me fee I used to have so many food rules that made me feel tired, irritable and constantly guilty for breaking them. 😪
.
🤦🏻‍♀️One of them involved not eating after a certain time (and ignoring hunger). Another involved avoiding anything made with flour, sugar, butter etc. I had so many of them... and for what?
.
🤷🏻‍♀️They didn’t make me “healthier” (read: thinner) they just made me stressed out and distracted from what’s REALLY important.
.
👀Some people will look at this photo and only see the foods they don’t allow themselves to eat, or foods they deem “unhealthy” and that’s ok.
.
👁And some people will see what I see - variety. And that’s what makes me feel my best!
.
😍This is pretty much what I eat as an intuitive eater although it changes every day. I always have the option to eat snacks. I almost always eat food after dinner (when I’m hungry!). And every day I eat something home cooked because that’s just my lifestyle (and that’s where meal prep fits in). I eat packaged foods every day too... and feel physically way better than when I tried to avoid them.
.
🤘🏼If you’re new to intuitive eating and want to learn more, check out my story highlights! I have a whole highlight about it. 
.
👩🏻‍🍳RECIPES for the blender muffins, sheet pan salmon meal and green rice burrito bowl are in the WWL Program! Learn more and hop on a free trial in my bio link!
Its free recipe Friday! Today we’re sharing our Its free recipe Friday! Today we’re sharing our mini chicken pot pies on workweeklunch.com. Head over to stories/story highlights under “free recipes” to grab the link!
.
This hack (only to be done with oven safe containers!) Helps cut down on dishes and bake time in the oven. You can do this with any casserole dish/bake! You can also freeze before baking and bake when ready to eat.
.
Let me know in the comments if you think you’ll try it!
Have you tried lavash bread? This lavash from @jos Have you tried lavash bread? This lavash from @josephspitabread is super satisfying, delicious and easy to use for any wrap you're craving. I love that it’s freezer-friendly too!
.
🌯I could eat these crunchy fresh veggies bundled up in a lavash bread every day. Not pictured, but I used hummus as the base in these veggie roll-ups. Any spread you like would work!
.
🍅How to use lavash bread: Simply spread your fillings across the whole wrap, then roll it up (from the short end)! The more fillings, the better.
.
🔎Want to find @josephspitabread Lavash bread near you? Head over to  https://www.josephsbakery.com/find-in-store/ to see where you can grab some!
.
#josephspitabread #josephsbakery #ad
Load More... Follow on Instagram
Fork-Knife Created with Sketch.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact
Privacy Policy

Workweek Lunch. All rights reserved. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with prior permission of Workweek Lunch.